Best Toaster Ovens
Best Overall Toaster Oven
Best Small Toaster Oven (2-4 Slices)
Best Large Toaster Oven (4-6 Slices)
Best Air Fryer Toaster Oven
Best RV Toaster Oven
Whether you’re filling out your kitchen for the first time or looking to upgrade from a standard toaster, it can be tough to know what you’re looking for. For some, an oven that can effectively toast bread is sufficient. Others may be looking for a toaster than can do more, like air frying or baking.
We evaluated our favorite toasters based on factors like size, finish, heating type, capabilities, warranty, price, and more.
Your guide to choosing the best toaster oven
Size
Toaster ovens are typically stored on the counter, so get a good idea of how much space you can afford without compromising any free space you need. If you’d like you can also store the toaster in a cabinet or pantry. Just consider that you’ll have to take it out every time you want to use it, which may be cumbersome if you’re using it daily.
Another consideration you should make when it comes to size is what you’ll actually be using the toaster oven for. If you’re simply toasting slices of bread, you can probably go with a smaller model. If you’d like to be able to cook casseroles and larger dishes, be sure the oven is large enough to fit baking dishes. Also consider whether you’d like one rack or more.
User-friendliness
Take a moment to scrutinize the display — are there too many buttons and settings for your liking? Is there a digital display, a knob, or pushable buttons? The most user-friendly design depends on the user, so decide what features are important to you.
There’s also ease of cleaning to consider. No matter how hard you try, some crumbs will escape and settle at the bottom of the oven. Removable crumb trays and oven doors can make it easier to keep up with regular cleaning and thus extend the oven’s life.
Functions
Toaster ovens often have a number of preset modes in addition to the standard “toast” setting. These settings make it easier to cook certain foods properly. Typically, the more functions a toaster oven has, the more expensive it will be. Some common modes include:
- Broil
- Bake
- Pizza
- Bagel
- Air fry
- Roast
- Keep warm
- Reheat
Budget
In general, more features and capabilities means more money. If you’re looking at a pricier model, be sure you’re actually going to use the additional features you’re paying for. If not, a more basic model is a better choice.
On the other hand, don’t skimp on price if you’re trying to cook more advanced dishes in your oven. A basic toaster oven won’t deliver even cooking on many types of dishes.
A convection oven is most similar to a full-size oven in terms of heating method, which means it can cook many types of food well. It also means it’s going to be more expensive than a more basic toaster oven designed to simply toast bread and not much else.
Additional features
As you do your research, make note of additional functions and features that boost the toaster’s ease of use and functionality.
- Temperature capability — If you’re just toasting food, you shouldn’t have a problem with not enough heat. But larger dishes and frozen foods may require higher temperatures. Be sure the maximum temperature can achieve what you’re looking to cook.
- Finish — You want to make sure the toaster oven matches your kitchen aesthetic. Stainless steel is usually pretty compatible with most design schemes, and it’s durable, too.
- Consistent cooking — Convection ovens often offer the most even and consistent cooking.
- Automatic shutoff — If you tend to multitask, you probably also tend to forget you have something in the oven until you smell burning. Some toasters come with a feature that turns off the heat once your food is done.
- Warranty — Some brands offer warranties for several years. If that makes the purchase more comfortable for you, consider prioritizing a warranty.
Best Overall Toaster Oven
This toaster is a perfect blend of function, compact design, and affordability. It’s got just one shelf, but that one shelf can fit up to four slices of bread or 9” pizza. If you’re looking for a toaster oven that can handle 1-2 servings at a time without taking up too much counter space, this is a good option.
The toaster features four functions: baking, broiling, toasting and keeping warm. It isn’t the flashiest set of capabilities, but it does the job for someone looking for a basic toaster oven. It’s maximum temperature is 450°F, which is plenty for most dishes. It also features a 30-mintue timer, a precise toast setting, and a stay-on functionality to ensure your food never burns or goes cold.
The removable crumb tray is a nice touch, too, making it easier to quickly clean the oven in between deeper cleans. Overall, this toaster is an economical choice for someone looking for a toaster oven that covers all of the must-haves.
Best Small Toaster Oven (2-4 Slices)
Right away, this toaster oven’s standout feature is the roll-top door. Instead of hinging up to a 90 degree angle, the door rolls up and out of the way to give you easy access to your food. When the machine is hot, this can potentially save you from burning your hands when reaching inside to grab your food.
The toaster features three settings: bake, broil, and roast. Like a full-size over, you can adjust the rack’s position for optimal cooking. A baking pan comes with the oven, which is a plus if you don’t already have a pan small enough to fit this toaster. The interior is small, compared to some other models, but it can still fit four slices of toast at once.
With a removable crumb tray and door, this toaster is easy to care for, too. Simply detach the glass door and tray, scrub with soap and water, dry, and return to the toaster.
Best Large Toaster Oven (4-6 Slices)
Are you looking for a toaster with an extra-large capacity, one that can do more than just toast? This Toshiba toaster oven can fit 6 slices of bread, a 12 inch pizza, casseroles, or 4 pounds of chicken. With a convection fan and temperature range of 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, it can achieve all of your cooking needs. There’s also ten cooking functions, including rotisserie and defrost, which open up a world of possibilities.
This toaster oven gets points for user-friendliness, too. The digital display is bright, the control knobs are designed to be easy to turn, and the handle remains cool even when the oven is on.
The racks are adjustable, which gives you flexibility to use a variety of dish sizes. Lastly, the interior surface is nonstick, making it easy to wipe away any spills with a damp cloth.
In addition to the toaster, you’ll get a few add-ons, including a removable crumb tray, rotisserie kit and lifter, a baking rack, baking pan, and rack clamp. A one-year warranty is also included.
Best Air Fryer Toaster Oven
If you’re looking for a toaster oven that can truly do it all, look no further. This model can replace a microwave, a traditional oven, and an air fryer. It offers five cooking functions — bake, broil, toast, keep warm, and air fry — that are sure to come in handy both for everyday and special occasions.
The interior capacity is something special, too. It fits 8 slices of bread, a 12-inch pizza, or even a 9” x 13” pan. So whether you’re simply making a slice of toast, reheating leftovers or preparing dinner for the whole family, this toaster oven has you covered. There’s a 60-minute precision timer, perfect for long and short cooking jobs.
If you’re interested in the air fryer hype but are hesitant to require another kitchen appliance with just one function, this toaster oven is a perfect multipurpose solution. It comes with an air fry basket and several other accessories to make experimenting with new recipes easy and fun.
Best RV Toaster Oven
From the makers of the Instant Pot comes this futuristic-looking jack of all trades. This 10-in-1 machine is an air fryer, toaster oven, rotisserie oven, deep fryer, oilless mini-cooker, convection oven, dehydrator, roaster, warmer, reheater, and pizza oven. With so many functions, it’s a great option for those with limited space who need to make the most of every appliance.
Though it’s space-efficient, it can hold a 12-inch pizza or 6 slices of bread. Golden Quartz Technology delivers a fast and even cook, while the progress display shows each stage of cooking from start to finish. The temperature ranges from 170 to 450 °F, with customizable toasting levels. And if you’re taking this toaster on the road, don’t worry about overheating your car — the double-layer glass door keeps heat inside.
You’ll also get a number of accessories, including an enamel baking tray, stainless steel oven rack, an air fry basket, a rotisserie spit and forks, and more. If you’re looking for an all-purpose, heavy-duty toaster, this is a great choice.